When massive battles are staged for war movies it can be a major problem gathering historically accurate hardware for the scenes. Many classic weapons systems are unavailable for film use either because there are no more functioning examples or the equipment in question is owned by hostile states who aren't going to allow Hollywood to play with their toys. So what's a producer to do?
Make the most of what you've got. If all you have is friendly hardware, then you issue it to everybody.
This trope is fading with CGI able to provide any weapons system you need. Furthermore, Soviet equipment like T-34, T-55, and T-72 tanks are increasingly available for discount prices, as well as on loan from US-friendly former East Bloc states such as Poland and the Czech Republic. This can replace German equipment in World War II movies also, as the Germans and Soviets extensively studied each others' equipment: if a T-55 with cheap wooden and plastic add-ons is painted to look like a Panther, even many military buffs will be fooled.note But prior to its development it was not uncommon to see German Panzer divisions equipped with repainted American M47 tanks, the Luftwaffe flying P-51 Mustangs or Soviets flying Republic F-84 Thunderjets. Japanese Zeros were often played by North American T-6 Texan planes. One can even occasionally see a VW Type 181 Thing/Safari/Trekker from The '70s subbing for a World War II Kuebelwagen, even though the latter are by no means hard to come by. Warships (before CGI) were the most challenging, because they aren't to be found in enthusiasts' garages or even museum collections; filmmakers historically had to rely on models, wartime stock footage (often an Anachronism Stew), or, if Backed by the Pentagon, wildly inappropriate modern ships.
This trope also extends to individual weapons; many films and television shows will commonly have Chinese-made Norinco Type 56 assault rifles substituting for genuine Russian-made Kalashnikov rifles, and a German Walther PPK can occasionally stand in for a Russian Makarov pistol. It's also not uncommon for western films to feature Browning M2 heavy machine guns dressed up to look like a Soviet DShK.
Granted, except for the most obvious cases, most people (beyond a few military hardware aficionados) probably aren't going to know the difference either way.
Somewhat surprisingly, the obvious solution is rarely used: the "enemy" uses "friendly" equipment because they have limited resources and use captured equipment. Militaries do this a lot in real life when at war, particularly during World War II—though in the case of the latter, it was rarely practiced by Allies on the Western Front, in part due to their own air-superiority; as it turns out, Allied pilots had reeeeally itchy trigger fingers, and oftentimes identified ground units by their shape rather than the emblems strapped on the side, which understandably might be hard to do when you're swooping at 300mph, no matter how large you paint said emblem. As a result of this, an American or British tanker trying to make use of that abandoned King Tiger or Panther left behind by its crew may unfortunately find himself the victim of Friendly Fire.
See also Just Plane Wrong, Tanks, but No Tanks and Artistic License – Ships.
Examples:
open/close all folders
Anime & Manga
- Apparently done In-Universe in an episode of Macross 7, where Basara and Mylene respectively play Hikaru and Minmay during a movie shoot, and Basara's sleek bright red custom-made state-of-the-art VF-19 subs in for Hikaru's first generation VF-1 (which is blocky, predominantly white and overall looks nothing like the VF-19) just by having its normally forward-swept wings folded backwards and a prop FAST Pack strapped to it.
Films — Live-Action
- Battle of Britain
- The film uses Spanish-built (and Rolls-Royce Merlin-engined!) versions of Messerschmitt Bf-109 fighters and Heinkel He-111 bombers, plus some real Spitfires. Together, they managed to put together the world's 35th largest air force at the time. Some Just Plane Wrong cases though, due to lack of available planes.
- In addition, because there weren't anywhere near as many Hurricanes available as Spitfires, some long shots of Hurricane squadrons in flight are actually the '109s after a quick repainting (Which is somewhat justified as the Merlin engine gave HA-1112, the Spanish BF-109, a profile that resembles the Hurricane from certain angles more than the original version note . ).
- And if one wants to get really pedantic, most of the Spitfires are later versions with considerable differences to the airframe and engine.
- The Spanish built CASA 2.111s and Hispano Aviacion HA-1112s were mostly used as they were airworthy, having been used by the Fracoist Spanish Air Force well into the 1950s!
- Battle of the Bulge had American M47 Patton tanks (painted in grey - which is completely incorrect for the period of the battle) standing in for German K?nisgtigers and M24 Chaffees standing in for the M4 Sherman. There is exactly one instance where this trope has been averted regarding the K?nisgtiger (there's only one still in running condition in the world, owned by the Saumur tank museum in France), that being the film Snow and Fire (and the tank had an engine breakdown on this one, thus discouraging the museum from lending it for further filmings).
- The Battle Of The River Plate (1956) used an American heavy cruiser, USS Salem, to substitute for the German pocket battleship Graf Spee since the real ship was scuttled after the battle. The British ships, by way of contrast, were played either by the actual ships that took part or by a ship of the same or similar class. Notably the film gave the ships prominent "acting credits" in the opening titles (HMS Sheffield as HMS Ajax, HMS Jamaica as HMS Exeter, INS Delhi (formerly HMNZS Achilles) as HMNZS Achilles and USS Salem as Admiral Graf Spee).
- Nearly became this trope with Black Hawk Down, when Ridley Scott had to buy Huey helicopters painted black to potentially stand in for the Black Hawks, which the Department of Defence was reluctant to lend for the film and civilian versions weren't available. To Scott's relief, the DoD eventually relented and lent them the Black Hawks for filming.
- Averted and played straight in A Bridge Too Far. Many of the halftracks for both the British and the Germans are genuine. The ones for XXX Corps had many of their parts stripped over the years, hence why the majority of them are used for scenes of the Allies assembling prior to the operation (if you look closely, you can see many of them missing components). The Panthers in Arnhem are played by post-war Leopard 1s of the Dutch Army.
- The Caine Mutiny: The USS Caine, supposedly a WWI-era Clemson/Wickes-class destroyer converted to a destroyer-minesweeper (DMS), was played by the very different WWII-era USS Thompson, a Gleaves-class destroyer which was brand spanking new in 1943, but which at least was also a DMS conversion.
- Captain America: The First Avenger: In an In-Universe example, one of Cap's war propaganda films features a tank that is obviously not a German Panzer, but an M3 Stuart with a Balkenkreuz painted on it.
- Casablanca: A Luftwaffe officer flies to Morocco in a Fokker Super Universal instead of a Junkers Ju 52, as the latter was only available in Germany during World War II. After the war, many working Ju 52s became available for period films.
- Downfall (2004): A troop of Hitler Youth are using a Soviet-made 85mm M1939 (52-K) air defense gun for the Battle of Berlin. It is likely supposed to represent the ubiquitous German 88mm Flak, but could also be justified that they are so short on weapons that they are being forced to utilize captured equipment, which, as mentioned above, is a rarity for this trope.
- Dunkirk:
- Extremely rare German Bf-109 fighter planes were substituted by Spanish HA-1112
aircraft (the Spanish-built variant of the BF-109 with the Rolls-Royce Merlin engine mentioned above for the Battle of Britain.). The latter can be distinguished from the former by its "smiley face" Rolls-Royce Merlin engine (which also ironically powers both the Supermarine Spitfire and the P/F-51 Mustang); the production of Dunkirk cleverly avoids the display of the distinctive engines by never depicting the planes in close-up shots. Instead, viewers only prominently see the "German" aircraft from the rear from the perspective of Farrier's gunsights outside of a brief flyby from the perspective of the Moonstone at sea. Meanwhile, the lack of any airworthy Heinkel He-111 bombers forced the production to resort to remote-controlled replicas◊.
- The French Navy T 47-class destroyer Maillé-Brézé, commissioned in 1957 and a museum ship since 1988, stands in for two Royal Navy V-class destroyers, HMS Vivacious, hull number D36, and HMS Vanquisher, D54, due to her similar silhouette to the V-class. The filmmakers painted D36 on her port bow and stern, and D54 on the starboard bow. A studio lot replica of Vivacious was used for the (ahistoricalnote ) scene where the destroyer is sunk.
- Extremely rare German Bf-109 fighter planes were substituted by Spanish HA-1112
- Empire of the Sun featured a Soviet GAZ-69 jee... uh, light troop carrier as an Imperial-era Japanese military SUV.
- Fire Birds, as with many of the television examples below, uses the ubiquitous MD 500 as the Big Bad's fictious "Scorpion" helicopter, as well as a SAAB 35 Draken as an unidentified enemy jet fighter. US Army helicopters were portrayed by type-correct aircraft.
- Averted in For Your Eyes Only, where the movie actually managed to hire an Mi-2 helicopter from the PZL ?widnik factory in Poland to come out to Greece, along with a Polish pilot and mechanic. The registration number was changed on screen, but the PZL ?widnik is clearly visible.
- The Great Raid: In order to provide cover for the Rangers as they make the final approach to the camp, an airplane is sent to overfly the area to distract the Japanese, allowing them to get into position without being spotted. This occurred during the historical raid, in which a P-61 Black Widow night fighter* was sent under orders to perform a few aerobatics and alter his power settings to make it sound from the ground as if he were experiencing an engine failure. However, there are no remaining airworthy P-61s, so instead the film utilized a Lockheed Ventura light bomber for this scene.
- A double example in The Hunt for Red October when a damaged Navy fighter is trying to land back on the carrier USS Enterprise (CVN-65). The shot of the plane approaching shows a period-appropriate F-14 Tomcat. After briefly cutting away, the film switches to the actual footage of Cdr. George Duncan's F9F-2 Panther's 1951 ramp strike while attempting to land on USS Midway (CV-41). Thus we have an F9F standing in for the Tomcat, and USS Midway standing in for Enterprise.
- The Hunters had American Republic F-84F Thunderstreaks subbing for North Korean MiG-15s.
- Iron Eagle I and Iron Eagle II featured Israeli C2 Kfir jets (modifed French Mirage III's) and American-built F-4 Phantom II fighters as Arab MiG's. It also used Israeli F-16 variants as American ones, due to lack of backing by the Pentagon. Aces: Iron Eagle III has rebuilt WW2 warbirds playing themselves, with the exception of a recycled "Zero" T-6 from Tora! Tora! Tora! and weirdly enough a prototype plane called the ARES playing the part of a Me-263.
- In Is Paris Burning?, an American M24 Chaffee was mocked up as a German Panther.
- Jet Pilot (1957) had Janet Leigh as a defecting Soviet pilot flying a Lockheed F-80 Shooting Star.
- Kelly's Heroes: Three modified T-34s were used as Tigers, and a number of Yugoslav equipment, trucks and a single-engines trainer were used to represent American and German equipment. The most noticeable is an FN variant of the BAR, which uses a pistol grip, that the production crew tried their best to hide by putting a neckerchief on the soldier operating it.
- The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: The "stand-in for Nazi Germany" terrorist faction, among other weapons, employs British tanks of the line MK I to MK IV from WW I era.
- Lord of War: Many of the Soviet weapons, especially those purported to be the AK-47, are actually the outdated AKM, the East German AKMS, the Czech SA Vz. 58, or the Chinese Norinco Type 56-1 (all derivatives of the AK-47 family). Many of the rifles were real guns rented from an actual arms dealer rather than props.
- Midway (1976): The film uses the T-6 Texan as a stand-in for Japanese planes. Most of the scenes showing American TBD Devastators and SBD Dauntlesses are depicted using SB2U Vindicators. Several restored FM-2 Wildcats were used to represent the F4F-4s, though this is much more justified as the FM-2 is a late-war variant of the F4F and looks mostly identical. Mockups of SBD Dauntless dive bombers and TBD Devastator torpedo bombers also appear in some hangar sequences. Midway is also infamous for using historical stock footage anachronistically, resulting in scenes that show aircraft which did not exist at the time of the battle. Towards the end, there's even a brief shot of an American post-war jet fighter (possibly a F9F Panther)crashing onto the deck of a carrier.
- Czechoslovak 1968 film Nebe?tí jezdci (The Sky Riders) (about World War II Czechoslovak airmen in the RAF) featured a mock-up of Vickers Wellington bomber, based upon a Lisunov Li-2 (Soviet licence production DC-3) transport. Sounds perhaps a bit strange - but the result was a quite convincing impression◊ of the Wellington, though not capable of flight.
- In Never Say Never Again, the underbelly of a Concorde is used to double for a B-1B Lancer. However, establishing shots of an actual B-1B Lancer taking off and in flight were used. The underbelly substitute likely had to do with the fact that the Lancer was still in the prototype phase at the time, and the USAF were really cagey about giving anyone too close a look at the Lancer in detail.
- The late 60s/early 70s Soviet Osvobozhdenie (Liberation) film series features T-44 (a stepping stone between T-34 and T-54/55) as reasonably well done Tigers and IS-2s as Panthers. Less well done are the use of undisguised IS-3s during the first film's Kursk battle (two years before the IS-3 entered service), as well as undisguised T-55s, T-62s, and T-10s in some background shots. There also seems to be a habit of documentaries using footage of the fake-Tigers from these films, converted to black-and-white to pass it off as real footage.
- The movie Patton featured postwar M48 Patton tanks playing German tanks, and M41 Walker-Bulldogs as World War II American tanks. Also, the Heinkel He-111s used by the Afrika Korps are played by Spanish-built CASA 2.111s. The CASA 2.111 was a Spanish built version of the Heinkel, after the war and using Rolls-Royce Merlin engines. Notably, there were more airworthy ones available than the Heinkel.
- The Michael Bay movie Pearl Harbor managed to play this trope straight and avert it, often in the same scene:
- Modern-day missile cruisers and destroyers (sometimes with wooden boxes to hide the missile launchers, sometimes not) play the smaller ships in Pearl Harbor during the attack.
- A reasonably accurate reproduction of the Japanese carrier Akagi in most shots, save a long shot where a modern nuclear-powered supercarrier was rather inexplicably used instead.
- Modern angled-deck aircraft carrier playing the USS Hornet during the Doolittle's Raid sequence, with reasonably good reproduction and restored B-25s (of a model which didn't exist until a year after the raid) flying off it.
- Red Dawn (1984): Aerospatiale Puma helicopters with added doodads play Mi-24 "Hind-A" helicopters (a very good likeness of the "Hind-A"). A mock-up of a T-72 tank was so accurate it caught the attention of two CIA men who wanted to know where it had come from. One of the Pumas was reused in Rambo: First Blood Part II and again in Rambo III, with the fake canopy removed because it created unsafe flight characteristics. The pylons were kept as they were solid modifications that did not effect airworthiness.
- Saving Private Ryan used quite realistically mocked-up T-34/85 tank as a substitute for the Tiger tank, and one of the Marders III self-propelled anti tank guns was a modern mock-up, based on the surviving Praga TNH/Pz 38 (t) chassis - virtually the same as the original Marder III used, the other was visually modified Swedish assault gun Sav m/43, also based on the Praga TNH chassis.
- Sink the Bismarck! used the actual aircraft carrier HMS Victorious to portray both itself and the Ark Royal. However, the ship had been modernized prior to filming to permit it to operate jet aircraft, leading to a zigzagged example of this trope.
- Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home: Uhura and Chekov beam into the nuclear aircraft carrier USS Enterprise, which was actually played by the non-nuclear USS Ranger as the Big-E was at sea at the time. Even if she wasn't, the Enterprise's reactor area was classified. Filming angle tried to use Nichelle Nichols' hair to obscure the conventional rectangular island and funnels of the conventionally-powered aircraft carrier.
- Tora! Tora! Tora! is based around the bombing of Pearl Harbour. It has a bunch of then-modern ships standing in for the vessels under attack, and a bunch of North American T-6 Texan trainers extensively rebuilt to look like the Japanese carrier aircraft. Some of these rebuilds went on to appear in Midway and Pearl Harbor. Most of the American planes are actual restored planes or reasonably good scale models. At the time of filming, there were no flyable Japanese Zeroes in existence, hence the use of the T-6 Texan.
- Top Gun:
- The (fictional) MiG-28 fighters are played by American F-5E Tiger II fighters.
- The TOPGUN instructors fly A-4 Skyhawks in order to simulate the performance of Soviet fighters. This makes for something of a zigzagged trope on a meta level: the Skyhawks are portraying Skyhawks... whose role is to portray MiGs.note
- Under Siege has the battleship USS Alabama and submarine USS Drum depicting the USS Missouri and a North Korean submarine, respectively.
- USS Indianapolis: Men of Courage: The South Dakota-class battleship USS Alabama and Gato-class submarine USS Drum are used to depict the Indianapolis and I-58, respectively, due to the fact that no pre-WWII-era "Treaty" Cruisers nor Japanese submarines are afloat to this day.
- White Tiger was supposed to use a very high-quality Tiger replica, which, due to Development Hell, was not complete on time. Instead they went with a dressed-up IS-2, with its turret placement noticeably different, and a result looking more like Porsche's Tiger prototype than the Henschel design. This is the least weird thing about that tank.
- Zulu: Some of the British defenders at Rorke's Drift are using the Martini-Henry rifle that would have been appropriate for the British Army in 1871. Possibly because only a few exist today in museums and private collections and it was impossible to borrow one for every actor and extra, the majority of men are equipped, for the film, with Lee-Enfield SMLE rifles introduced in the 1910's. In The '60s, these were available in abundance, even though an anachronism for the film. The Lee-Enfields were made to look more like the single-shot Martini-Henry by the simple expedient of removing the magazines, obliging the people using them to reload after every single shot.
- The Russian film Zvezda (The Star) had several mocked-up T-54 or T-55 tanks, which made reasonably believable Tiger I tanks. Not as well done as in Band of Brothers (also a T-54/55) or Kelly's Heroes (T-34-85 tanks), though.
Live-Action TV
- In Season 5 of 24 a Russian SSGN is played by an American submarine.
- Airwolf uses American MD 500 Defender helicopters to play Soviet and Soviet-made choppers on a frequent basis.
- Arrow described a Strela launcher (with a range of under ten kilometers) as a SA-300 (a much larger missile with a range of as much as four hundred kilometers) and claimed it had a range of 2,400 kilometers, before using it to attempt to shoot down an aircraft flying straight overhead.
- In the Horatio Hornblower series, the 64-gun HMS Indefatigable is played by the 20-gun Grand Turk.
- Magnum, P.I. once used an MD 500 series chopper to play an "experimental attack helicopter". Amusingly enough, T.C., who was brainwashed into flying it, uses the same model in his day job. One wonders why he didn't notice.
- In SEAL Team, a UH-60 Blackhawk is used to play an Indian Air Force helicopter in the season 2 finale, owing to the unavailability of actual Indian helicopters in California where filming takes place. When the episode was aired, India's helicopter fleet did not have any American designs in it, and while U.S.-made helicopters were eventually ordered by the IAF, they were only the AH-64 Apache and CH-47 Chinook models.
- In an episode of Sons of Guns, a customer wants to put together a quad-.50cal for demonstrations at air shows. Because this would cost $60,000 + ~$4-$5 per bullet, they instead build and mount four MG-42s, which costs only about $8,000 and $0.30 per bullet. (Flem notices the irony of using the enemy's weapon as a stand-in; cut to a Confession Cam scene where he apologizes to his WWII veteran grandfather.)
- The short-lived series Supercarrier featured an American F-16 Fighting Falcon playing the (fictitious) MiG-28. Or, at least it did for the majority of shots. Then in the one sequence, the same plane was "played" by footage of an F-16, an F-5, very blatant Stock Footage of an F-14 and, finally, a very obvious model of an F/A-18. Supercarrier was like that.
Music Videos
- The music video for "Sunset (Bird of Prey" by Fatboy Slim features a late-model Hawker Hunter painted in US Air Force livery, possibly to represent an F-105 Thunderchief. The resemblance from most angles isn't bad even if their performance isn't remotely comparable.
Tabletop Games
- Flames of War created their own Hollywood Tiger game/objective piece as an homage to various World War II films.
- Invoked by Warlord Games, the creators of the World War II wargame Bolt Action, which released a "Hollywood Tiger Tank" miniature modeled on the T34-based Tiger replicas used in Kelly's Heroes as a homage to the film. Otherwise averted with their historically accurate vehicle range and army lists.
Real Life
- British WW I tanks of the line MK I to MK IV are often cast as German mobile armor (or some other stand-in villainous faction) despite being - well, British.
- American-made aircraft stand in for enemy planes in air-to-air combat training programs:
- TOPGUN (nowadays replaced by the Naval Strike and Air Warfare Center, or NSAWC for short) used F-5E Tiger II fighters and A-4 Skyhawk light attack aircraft were used to play Soviet aircraft. Presently, US Navy aggressor squadrons operate F/A-18 Hornet fighters, with plans to move to the F/A-18F Super Hornet. US Air Force aggressor squadrons flew F-16s and F-15s, and are now setting up an F-35 aggressor squadron to simulate enemy stealth fighters.
- US Navy and USMC also operated Israeli produced Kfir fighters (designated F-21s) as a training substitute for MiG-23s - though visually quite dissimilar, they had similar flight characteristics.
- F/A-18s were used to simulate MiG-29 fighters.
- In addition to the Air Force, Navy and Marines operating aggressor units, the Private Military Contractors Draken International and Airborne Tactical Advantage Company also contract out as aggressors for pilot training. Draken has a few real MiGs among their fleet, and ATAC has 6 of the ex-Navy F-21 Kfirs. Both companies hire former US military fighter pilots (and occasionally Air National Guard pilots who are still also flying Air Force F-16s on weekends) to fly their jets.
- Sikorsky H-19/S-55 helicopters which were used in lieu of Soviet Hind helicopters. They not only played the part, they were actually dressed up for the part as well. The final result looks remarkably Hind-like — the likeness was even better than the dressed up choppers in Red Dawn (1984), Rambo: First Blood Part II and Rambo III.
- During the Cold War, Army units at Fort Irwin, California used M551 Sheridan light tanks and humvees dressed up to imitate Soviet T80 tanks and BRDM scout vehicles, respectively. The Sheridans have been replaced by dressed-up M1 Abrams (nicknamed the "M1 KVT" or "Krasnovian Variant Tank"). Of course, these don't see quite as much use these days as most training presently focuses on The War on Terror.
